Eli Manning vs. Peyton Manning, Who’s the Better Manning? – Survey of the Day

Now that the dust has settled on Eli Manning’s second Super Bowl victory — and second Super Bowl MVP title — it’s time to compare the legacy of this New York Giants quarterback with that of his older brother, 11-time Pro Bowler and four-time regular season MVP, Peyton Manning.

According to a survey from Poll Position of 632 adult self-described football fans, 44 percent say that Peyton is still the better QB, whereas 25 percent believe Eli has now surpassed him. Thirty-two percent have no opinion or haven’t made up their minds yet.

The younger brother did have slightly more support from the youngest of the survey’s respondents. 37 percent of the 18- to 29-year-olds who answered the survey said that Eli was the better QB, whereas 47 percent of that demographic went with Peyton.

[Poll Position]